You’ve been feeling lonely lately, and when a friend asks how you’re doing, you say “good, busy” because saying more feels like asking for too much. Somewhere along the way you decided that keeping things to yourself was the safer move. This episode looks at what that choice might be costing you.
Daniela opens with the night her 20-year college reunion turned into a string of confessions, all because she answered “where’s your husband?” with the truth, and the story sets up a way to decide when to share personal information that counts what silence costs.
She also shares a story from her practice about a client who was quietly struggling with depression and looked fine to everyone around her. Afraid of burdening people, the client kept pulling back, which left her more alone. You’ll hear what happened when Daniela asked her to tell one trusted friend the truth, and what the friend shared in return. Daniela is clear that more disclosure isn’t always better, and some things stay private.
Here’s what’s covered:
- Why the fear of judgment makes silence feel safe, and what Leslie John’s studies found about how people see someone who declines to answer
- What self-concealment research says about hiding what you’re going through, and why people who look fine on the outside are so good at it
- How opposite action works, and why it asks you to do the reverse of what your emotions are telling you
- The four questions for weighing a decision to share, including the two most of us skip, tested on a dinner with a close friend
- How to figure out what’s true, relevant, and appropriate for the relationship you want with a specific person
- One small truth to try this week in place of the automatic answer
Some of us stay quiet because we don’t want to seem needy, then wonder later whether it cost us a closer friendship. If you’re working on being vulnerable in relationships, this episode gives you a way to think it through, so building connection stops depending on how brave you feel that day.
"People can only connect to the version of us that we give them access to."
Daniela
If you try the four questions this week, Daniela wants to hear how it went. And if you know someone who answers everything with “I’m fine,” send them this episode.
Mentioned Resources
Hiding Personal Information Reveals the Worst
The Surprising Benefits of Oversharing
The Role of Need Satisfaction in Self-concealment and Well-being.
Why is Concealment Associated with Health and Wellbeing? An Investigation of Potential Mechanisms
Show People How ‘Your Brain Works’: Leslie John on the Art of Oversharing
Connect with Daniela
This podcast is brought to you in partnership with Leah Bryant Co.
The unedited transcript for this episode of Manual Not Included
The Importance of Connection and Belonging
Daniela Tempesta [00:00:39 - 00:01:23]: And that matters because feeling connected, supported, and like we belong is associated with better wellbeing. And you know what isn't associated with better wellbeing? Hiding our truth. Research on self-concealment has found that people who hide more of what they're going through also tend to report more anxiety, depression, and psychological distress. So it turns out there can be a cost to saying too little too. And that's what today's episode is about. We're gonna talk about what can happen when we take the risk of sharing a little bit more. We'll look at some fascinating research on the cost of sharing too little, and then I'll present you with a framework for deciding when to open up and when it actually makes sense to keep something to yourself. But I wanna start with a story about something that happened at my 20-year college reunion.
A Story from My 20-Year College Reunion
Daniela Tempesta [00:01:24 - 00:01:58]: Because this is one of those moments where I really saw the power of sharing play out in real time. Now, you know how reunions go, like there's this subtle, okay, let's be real, overt pressure to sum up your life in a way that sounds pretty fantastic. And it's super easy to slip into highlight reel mode and just share the good stuff. So when someone asked me, where's your husband? I remember I had this little fork in the road moment. I could make up a lie. Oh, he couldn't make it, or he's home with our kid. Or I could tell the truth. And I decided to go with the truth.
Telling the Truth at the Reunion
Daniela Tempesta [00:01:58 - 00:02:24]: We're getting divorced, I said. And I probably said it 50 times that day. And almost every single time people made that same face, you know, that, oh shit, I just stepped in emotional dog poop face. And they'd say, oh, I'm so sorry. And I'd say, don't say sorry. Say congratulations. It's hard, but it's a good thing. But then something really interesting started happening as the night went on and people got looser.
Permission to Be Honest
Daniela Tempesta [00:02:25 - 00:03:04]: Okay, let's be honest, drunker. People started finding me in the bathroom, in line for the bar while I was trying to walk to my Uber, pulling me aside and saying things I'm pretty sure they weren't planning on sharing at the beginning of the day. Tell me about your divorce. I'm actually really miserable in my marriage. I think about leaving all the time, but I'm scared. What about the kids? And I remember thinking, wow, by telling the truth about what was actually happening in my life, I'd somehow given other people permission to tell the truth about theirs. Suddenly we weren't talking about promotions and houses and all the shiny things we'd accumulated since college. We were actually talking about our real lives.
The Power of Truthful Sharing
Daniela Tempesta [00:03:05 - 00:03:52]: And that experience has always stuck with me because by telling the truth, I seemed to make it a little easier for other people to tell the truth about them. And it allowed us to connect more. So for me, my reunion was a clear example of the benefit of sharing more. But let's look at the other side of this. What's the potential downside of not sharing enough? I mean, did you even know there was one? Harvard Business School professor Leslie John studies self-disclosure, and a lot of her work looks at exactly this question. Now, we all know about TMI, too much information. But John's work also draws attention to what she calls TLI, too little information. And in one series of studies, she and her colleagues found that people tended to underestimate the social costs of withholding information.
The Social Cost of Withholding
Daniela Tempesta [00:03:53 - 00:04:27]: They found that when people deliberately chose not to answer, other people tended to see them as less trustworthy and judge them more negatively. And interestingly, people who did disclose were sometimes viewed more positively, even when what they disclosed was not particularly flattering. Now, obviously this doesn't mean you owe people answers to all personal questions. You don't. But what I think is interesting is the assumption underneath it. We tend to think, if I say something, something bad could happen. If I don't say anything, nothing happens. But John's work shows us that that's not necessarily true.
Personal and Social Consequences of Not Sharing
Daniela Tempesta [00:04:28 - 00:05:21]: Saying nothing can have social consequences, like being perceived as less trustworthy. And there's a cost on a personal level too. There's a whole body of research around something called self-concealment, which is basically the tendency to actively hide personal information that feels distressing or difficult. And across the research, higher self-concealment has been associated with things like more anxiety, more depression, psychological distress, and poor psychological wellbeing. And I have seen this in my practice so many times. I'm thinking of one particular client of mine who was quietly struggling with depression. She was very high functioning on the outside, so people really wouldn't have known. And she was so afraid of burdening people with what she was going through or being judged for it that her instinct was just to keep pulling back and not say anything, which of course only added insult to injury.
Case Study: The Impact of Withholding
Daniela Tempesta [00:05:21 - 00:06:08]: She was already feeling low and alone, and now she was even more alone with that feeling. So we decided to work with a concept called opposite action, which basically means doing the opposite of what your emotions are telling you to do. Her depression was telling her, stay quiet, keep this to yourself. So instead, I asked her to pick one friend she trusted and tell her that even though things probably looked fine on the outside, she'd actually been struggling with depression. And her friend responded in this incredibly warm, authentic way. She not only expressed compassion for her, but she told her that she'd gone through a period of debilitating depression in her early 20s. And suddenly my client wasn't being judged and she wasn't burdening her friend. She was being understood and she definitely felt less alone.
Learning to Assess When to Share
Daniela Tempesta [00:06:09 - 00:07:16]: And I think that's such a good example of what can happen when we don't automatically let fear decide what we share and what we keep to ourselves. Now, this doesn't mean that telling everyone your secrets is some magical cure for depression. But I think all of this does suggest that not sharing is not necessarily the neutral consequence-free option we tend to assume it is. Sometimes there is a cost to saying too little. So how do you know when to share and when not to? Well, Leslie John has a really useful way of thinking through exactly that. She suggests looking at 4 sides of the decision. One, what's the risk of telling? Or sharing? 2, what could I gain by telling? 3, what's the risk of not telling? And 4, what could I gain by keeping this to myself? And I think this is worth slowing down for because otherwise those 4 questions sound like a nice little list and we just go back to doing things the way we were doing them before, right? So let's actually use it. Let's say you're having dinner with a close friend and you guys are talking about how things are going, and the truth is You've been feeling really lonely lately.
Assessing the Risks and Benefits of Sharing
Daniela Tempesta [00:07:17 - 00:07:39]: Most of us will very quickly think about the potential risks of sharing that. Maybe she'll think you're needy. Maybe you feel pathetic saying it out loud. Maybe she gives you advice you absolutely did not ask for. And the benefit of keeping it to yourself? Well, that's easy. You don't have to feel exposed. You get to keep looking like you have it all together. But let's look at the questions we're less likely to ask.
What You Might Gain By Opening Up
Daniela Tempesta [00:07:40 - 00:08:13]: The part of the equation we tend to miss. What might you gain by telling her? Well, maybe you tell her and she says, oh my goodness, me too. Or maybe she says, that sounds really hard. But either way, you feel a little less alone. And what's the risk if you don't share? Maybe you leave dinner disappointed that you didn't really connect or feel seen. Maybe you feel angry at your friend for not reading your mind. Maybe you feel even more lonely than when you got there. Now look, going through these 4 questions doesn't tell you what to do.
Intentional, Appropriate Sharing
Daniela Tempesta [00:08:13 - 00:08:52]: It doesn't give you the answer. It just makes sure you're considering the full picture, including the part we usually miss: the cost of not sharing. And I wanna be clear, I'm not arguing that more disclosure is always better. Some things are private. And sometimes there are very real consequences to sharing. The goal isn't to tell everyone everything. It's to be intentional about what you share and what you don't, because people can only connect to the version of us that we give them access to. If the only version you show people is the competent, successful, funny, busy, I'm doing great, just one foot in front of the other version, that's the version people are gonna respond to.
Connection Requires Vulnerability
Daniela Tempesta [00:08:54 - 00:09:58]: And then you can end up surrounded by people and still feel completely unseen. Not because nobody cares, but because you actually haven't let them see you. Okay. So what do you do with this information? Well, I would encourage you to ask yourself, what's one small change that you can make? And rather than automatically assuming that telling the truth is TMI, you could start to ask, what's the right amount of information to share for the kind of relationship I actually want to have with this person? What's true, relevant, and appropriate for this relationship in this moment? Because if you want intimacy, at some point you have to actually give people access to something real. So this week, notice the moments when you wanna automatically give the I'm fine version of things. And when you're faced with a decision of how much to share, think about both sides of the equation, not just what might happen if you say something, But also what you might lose by not saying it. And you can try being just a little bit more honest. Just one step, one small truth.